Barrel Break-In and Practical Accuracy Testing
Barrel Break-In: Does It Really Matter?
There are no shortage of controversial topics in the firearm industry. Much like the classic ā9mm vs. 45 ACPā and āAR vs. AKā debates, it seems like many shooters have a very strong opinion on the subject of barrel break-in. While the discussion tied to barrel break-in is normally tied to the effective management of copper fouling building up in the lands and grooves of your rifling, there are a number of other influences that may dictate your barrelās natural ābreak-in processā. Itās not unusual to see a slight increase of velocity over the first few hundred rounds of a barrelās life. Itās also common to see a slight reduction in group size after sending a few rounds through a new barrel. This phenomenon proved to be readily apparent during a recent range trip with one of our shop test rifles, a build that was specifically designed to replicate a practical field rifle setup carried by an amateur shooter engaging a paper target at a distance of 100 yards.The Practical Test Rifle
In an optimal load testing environment, we would mount a barrel to a custom action bolted to a test fixture placed in climate controlled conditions, firing hand-loaded ammunition tailored to that specific barrel. While this approach may provide a better reflection of a rifle barrelās true performance capability, its value in a field environment is somewhat limited. For this reason, we had our local gunsmith construct our own āfield rifleā designed to reflect parts and accessories commonly seen at your local rifle range.Build Specifications:
- Vortakt 500 Series Barrel
- Remington 700 Short Action Receiver (Not Trued)
- Grayboe Renegade Fiberglass Stock (Not Bedded)
- Timney 510 Trigger
- Harris 6ā-9ā BRMS Bipod
- Vortex Golden Eagle 15-60x SFP Optic
- Talley Lightweight 1 Piece Scope Mount
About the Barrel:
The barrel used for this initial round of testing was machined from one of our 500 Series single-point cut rifled blanks. Featuring a hand-lapped 4R rifled bore, this particular Vortakt barrel is profiled to an M24 contour and a 1:7.5 twist rate. The chamber was reamed from a SAAMI spec 6mm Creedmoor reamer, set +.002 over minimum SAAMI headspace specifications.The Break-In Test
For our initial break-in testing we utilized two common factory loads from Hornady and Berger. The Hornady Match factory load features their 108gr. ELD bullet, while the Berger factory load showcases their 105gr. Hybrid Match bullet design. The rifle was supported from the bipod and a rear bag, fired at a paper target set up at 100 yards. Rounds 1-5 through the barrel were used for preliminary sight-in, and were not measured for group size. The initial five rounds fired for group size (rounds #6-10) measured in at .62 MOA using the Hornady ELD Match load, followed by another five-round group using the Berger 105 gr. Hybrid Target load (rounds #11-15). Once this first group of Berger factory ammunition was fired, we cleaned the bore with a few patches of Hoppeās #9 to remove residual carbon fouling. The patches did not come out blue, and a quick inspection determined that no copper fouling was visible. Rounds #16-20 were fired with the Hornady ammunition, demonstrating a slight decrease in group size when compared with the initial five-round group. Once again we cleaned the bore with a few patches of Hoppeās #9, this time firing a five-round group with the Berger factory load. This final five-round group (rounds #21-25) provided us with a .38 MOA group, the tightest fired during this range session.The Preliminary Verdict
While the results of this test may be anecdotal in nature, early indications point to a gradual break-in of the barrel over the first 25 rounds, with group size further improved by leveraging a light break-in process. This correlates with past results achieved using a similar approach to barrel break-in.
Shots |
Ammunition Brand |
Bullet Type |
Bullet Weight (grains) |
Barrel Cleaned Post Firing |
5 Shot Group – 100 Yards (MOA) |
1 – 5 |
Hornady |
ELD Match |
108 |
No |
Sight in |
6 – 10 |
Hornady |
ELD Match |
108 |
No |
0.62 |
11 – 15 |
Berger |
Hybrid Target |
105 |
Yes |
0.75 |
16 – 20 |
Hornady |
ELD Match |
108 |
Yes |
0.55 |
21 – 25 |
Berger |
Hybrid Target |
105 |
N/A |
0.38 |